Chp.10- Racism and Prejudice- Case Study Report

1. Statement of the Problem
A. Definition
Francine was a sophomore transfer student from Illinois. She met Tony, an African-American at her university in Louisiana. One day Tony asked Francine out to the bookstore and to have a cup of coffee. When they walked into the bookstore, some of the students cast glances at them disdainfully and even said something rude. However, those prejudice behaviors made no sense to Francine. She still went out with Tony no matter how other students thought about the relationship between Tony and her. As days passed by, whenever Francine and Tony hung out together, they were always disturbed by other students’ disrespectful words and even some physical conflicts. Although Francine‘s self-confidence was high and she was seldom affected by others’ opinions, she finally could not endure this kind of situation anymore. She could not believe that there is so much racial prejudice still existed.

B. Analysis
Francine and Tony belong to different races. Francine is from Illinois; however, Tony is an African-American. Their relationship was disturbed by other students’ prejudiced words. As a result, Francine was annoyed and desperate about the situation they faced.

2. Suggestion of Possible Solutions
(1).Francine and Tony do not have to care about what other students’ thought about their relationship. Keep their relationship.
(2). Francine should break up with Tony.
(3). Francine and Tony should tell university officers about the situation they faced.

3. Evaluation of Possible Solutions
(1). Advantage: By building their relationship well, they can prove to other students that there is no conflict between two different races.
Disadvantage: They will be still disturbed by others.
(2). Advantage: Once they separate, there will be no prejudiced words or physical conflicts between them.
Disadvantage: They cannot get along with each other.
(3). Advantage: University officers will give them some advises and build their confidence about their relationship.
Disadvantage: Other students will still continue disturbing Tony and Francine.

4. Selection of a Solution
A. Choice
Solution (1): Francine and Tony do not have to care about what other students’ thought about their relationship. Keep their relationship.
B. Justification
What Tony and Francine faced was a serious racial discrimination issue. No one can easily change other’s inherent thought. Even though Francine breaks up with Tony, the discrimination will still exist. Therefore, since the result will be the same no matter Tony and Francine separate or not, they will be much happier to get along with each other.

"Smoke Signals" Film Analysis Report

Summary and Analysis

Victor and Thomas are neighbors and they grew up together because of Victor’s father. Thomas was survived from a fire that killed his parents when he was an infant. The person who saved Thomas’s live was Victor’s father, Arnold. Therefore, Thomas extremely adores Arnold. However, Arnold is an alcoholic and violent person. He finally separated with Victor’s mother and left his family to Phoenix. Victor loves Arnold but also angers him.

One day, Victor decided to take a trip to Phoenix looking for Arnold. When Victor told Thomas about his plan to Phoenix, As a result, they went to Phoenix together. During the trip, they met other American people on the bus. They keep their Native American characteristics by talking to other American people with hard words and coldness. When they arrived their destination in Phoenix, they met a woman who used to work with Arnold. At that time, they knew that Arnold has already passed away. The woman told Victor a lot about Arnold’s story, including the truth that the fire was caused by Arnold. Victor finally realized why Arnold became an alcoholic, became violent and finally left his family.

Relation to Case Study

In chapter 10, Racism and Prejudice, the relationship between Francine and Tony was disturbed and annoyed by other students at university because of their different races. The similar situation related to prejudice is happened in this movie. When Victor and Thomas were on their way to Phoenix on the bus, Victor told Thomas that they should not be so friendly to others or others will not respect them. Also, Victor said that as being an American Indian, they should keep a “warrior face.” It is because of the prejudice from American people toward American Indians, Victor told Thomas to stand for their American Indian’s characteristics. Just like Tony told Francine not to be annoyed by others’ words and keep on their relationship.

Reaction to the movie

It is a big issue about different races both in chapter 10 and in this movie. Everyone should have his right to be treated fairly. Every person didn’t have chances to choose his race, skin color, and the language he speaks so no one should be prohibited doing something or building any relationship. Also, people do not have to change their native identity for others. Therefore, just like Victor and Thomas keep their identity as being American Indians, Francine and Tony should not separate by others’ judgements.